Are you searching for hostler compatibility or satisfactory durability? Are you a high-lumen seeker or need accidental discharge protections? Here is a brief comparison between Surefire XH35 and Streamlight TLR 1 HL. We’ll explain the details to help you choose between these top performers. But first, let’s quickly check out what makes the Surefire XH35 vs Streamlight TLR 1 HL stand out.
About Surefire XH35
SureFire XH35 Dual,1000 Lumens
The SureFire XH35 MasterFire Series WeaponLight ensures quick-draw efficiency in high-stress situations with the MasterFire Rapid Deploy Holster. Its MaxVision Beam® LED provides darkness-filling illumination at 1,000 or 300 lumens, complemented by a useful strobe feature. The weapon light accommodates optional pressure-activated DG switches for precision control without altering the weapon grip. Designed for most railed pistols, the XH35 features ambidextrous switches, a cam-slotted bezel, and rear locking lugs for secure weapon retention. With Mil-Spec hard-anodized aluminum construction, this recoil-proof LED light offers high-output performance for closer-range engagements.
Pros:
- Quick-draw efficiency with MasterFire Rapid Deploy Holster.
- Powerful MaxVision Beam® LED with 1,000 or 300 lumens and strobe feature.
- Compatibility with optional pressure-activated DG switches for precision control.
- Ambidextrous switches for ease of use.
- Secure weapon retention with cam-slotted bezel and rear locking lugs.
- Weatherproof construction with O-ring and gasket sealing.
Cons:
- Designed specifically for railed pistols, limiting compatibility with certain firearms.
About Streamlight TLR 1 HL
Streamlight 69260 TLR-1 HL 1000-Lumen Weapon Light
The Streamlight 69260 TLR-1 HL is a powerful 1000-lumen weapon light designed for handguns with Glock-style rails and MIL-STD-1913 (Picatinny) rails. With a concentrated beam and optimal peripheral illumination, it boasts white LED technology with a 50,000-hour lifetime. The rail grip clamp system allows quick, tool-free attachment and detachment without obstructing the muzzle. The package includes keys for various compatibility options, but verify fitment before purchase. The user-programmable strobe can be turned on or off and fits existing light-bearing holsters. Note: Batteries are not included.
Pros:
- Impressive 1000-lumen brightness.
- Versatile compatibility with different handgun models.
- Quick and secure rail grip clamp system.
- User-programmable strobe for added functionality.
- Fits existing light-bearing holsters.
Cons:
- Batteries are not included.
- Compatibility verification is required for specific handgun models.
Comparing Criteria: Surefire XH35 vs Streamlight TLR 1 HL
Hand Feel and Ergonomics
Weight and Durability:
- Surefire XH35 feels heavier and more robust than the polymer body of the TLR-1HL.
- XH35 provides a clear advantage in terms of weight and durability.
Activation Buttons:
- XH35 features large, easy-to-activate buttons for quick one-handed operation.
- TLR-1HL relies on a smaller, stiffer sliding rheostat, potentially requiring more precision.
Preventing Accidental Activation:
- XH35 incorporates positive clicks and strategic button placement to prevent accidental activation.
- TLR-1HL’s smaller sliding rheostat may be more prone to accidental activation in high-stress scenarios.
Toggle Settings:
- XH35 allows quick and easy toggling of settings with positive clicks.
- TLR-1HL’s design may demand more precision during adjustments, potentially slowing down the process.
Optional Tape Switches:
- Surefire XH35 vs Streamlight TLR 1 HL: both lights offer the option for tape switches, providing an alternate method of activation if desired.
Light Output: Spotlight vs Floodlight
Light Output Comparison:
TLR-1HL:
- It shines a super bright 1,000-lumen spot beam.
- Designed for maximum distance.
- Creates a focused bullseye beam shape.
XH35:
- Outputs a broader 1,500-lumen flood pattern.
- It provides more peripheral light, which is ideal for indoors.
- Balances wide visibility with concentrated intensity for distant targets.
Practical Illumination:
TLR-1HL:
- The spot beam is excellent for long-range identification.
- Offers a concentrated, spotlight-like illumination.
XH35:
- Flood patterns enhance situational awareness.
- Ideal for close ranges, illuminating walls and ceilings indoors.
- Maintains wider visibility even at lower settings.
Versatility:
TLR-1HL:
- Specialized for focused, long-distance illumination.
XH35:
- Balances both wide and long-range illumination.
- It is well-suited for various scenarios, providing flexibility in use.
Weapon Mounting and Holster Compatibility
Attachment Compatibility:
- Surefire XH35 vs Streamlight TLR 1 HL come with cross-slot Picatinny rail inserts for standard attachment to rifle handguards and barrels.
- TLR-1HL is compatible with existing X300/TLR holsters, ensuring ease of use for those already equipped with such holsters.
Holster Requirements:
- The longer XH35, with its 3.9-inch extended length, requires holsters specifically designed to accommodate its size.
- Holster fitting becomes crucial for XH35 users, ensuring a secure and optimal fit for the extended dimensions.
Handgun Application:
- When mounted on a handgun, the XH35’s additional size offers advantages.
- Allows the use of various muzzle attachments, such as compensators, without obstructing access to the rear switch.
- In contrast, the TLR-1HL may face limitations due to its more compact design on specific muzzle attachments.
Switch Accessibility:
- The extended length of the XH35 permits comfortable and unobstructed access to the rear switch when mounted on a handgun.
- TLR-1HL, being more compact, may pose challenges when utilizing specific muzzle attachments, potentially hindering switch access.
Versatility in Mounting Options:
- XH35’s extended size, while requiring specific holsters, offers versatility in mounting on different firearms, including those with various muzzle attachments.
- TLR-1HL, while compatible with existing holsters, may be more suitable for users who prioritize a more compact and streamlined design without additional muzzle attachments.
Durability & Features
Surefire XH35
- Battle-Proven Durability: Surefire weapon lights are renowned for their battle-proven durability, undergoing rigorous torture testing.
- Resilience Focus: The XH35 prioritizes resilience over extras, lacking features like the TLR-1HL’s integrated laser aiming module.
- Waterproof Design: With an IPX7 rating, the XH35 is designed to withstand water exposure, ensuring longevity.
- Corrosion-Resistant Finish: The anodized finish is corrosion-resistant, adding an extra layer of protection against wear and tear.
- Ballistic Polymer Construction: Constructed with ballistic polymer, the XH35 is built to survive years of daily carry, emphasizing longevity.
- Impact Absorption: Equipped with impact absorption recoil lugs, the XH35 prolongs dependable operation during pistol recoils.
- Accidental Discharge Protection: Recessed switch guards on the XH35 protect against unintentional discharges, enhancing real-world viability.
Streamlight TLR-1HL:
- Lifespan Metrics: The Streamlight TLR-1HL lacks longevity and reliability metrics similar to the Surefire XH35.
- Impact Absorption Recoil Lugs: Unlike the XH35, the TLR-1HL lacks impact absorption recoil lugs, potentially affecting its operation during pistol recoils.
- Accidental Discharge Protections: The TLR-1HL does not offer unintentional discharge protections such as recessed switch guards, introducing hazards to real-world viability.
Now you know the detailed comparison of Surefire XH35 vs Streamlight TLR 1 HL. You can read our comprehensive buyer’s guide for Glock laser light.
You may also like to read our comprehensive buyer’s guide on Surefire laser light.
Last Thought:
So, from the comparison between the Surefire XH35 vs Streamlight TLR 1 HL, the Surefire XH35 emerges as a standout choice, offering battle-proven durability, resilience-focused design, and unique features like impact absorption recoil lugs and accidental discharge protections. While the TLR-1HL remains a robust option, it may need to catch up regarding the lifespan longevity and reliability metrics provided by the XH35. When choosing between these two exceptional weapon lights, consider your specific requirements and priorities.