A bright weapon-mounted light is essential for target identification and accuracy in low-light conditions when outfitting a defensive or duty pistol. Two of the most popular lights for handguns are the Surefire X300 Ultra vs Streamlight TLR1 HL. While these models share some similarities, their performance and features differ meaningfully. Before we jump into the comparison, let’s quickly check out what makes these two products shine.
About Surefire X300 Ultra
SureFire X300 Ultra X300U-B High Output 1000 Lumen
Enhance your tactical edge with the SureFire X300 Ultra, delivering a potent 1000-lumen LED output for unmatched visibility. Engineered for durability, its virtually indestructible design withstands rigorous conditions. The custom TIR lens ensures a smooth, far-reaching light, emphasizing a more giant center spot beam. Ambidextrous momentary- and constant-on switches provide versatile control, while secure attachment to Universal and Picatinny rails guarantees stability. Twelve extra Surefire CR123A batteries and 3 Lightjunction battery cases for extended readiness are included. Note: New production models are NOT compatible with FN 509.
Pros:
- Powerful 1000 Lumen LED
- Durable and virtually indestructible
- Custom TIR lens for precise illumination
- Ambidextrous momentary- and constant switching
- Secure attachment to Universal and Picatinny rails
- Bonus: 12 extra Surefire CR123A batteries and 3 Lightjunction battery cases
Cons:
- New production models not compatible with FN 509
About Streamlight TLR1 HL
Streamlight 69260 TLR-1 HL 1000-Lumen Weapon Light
Experience top-tier performance with the Streamlight TLR-1 HL, a 1000-lumen powerhouse designed for tactical precision. Boasting White LED technology with a 50,000-hour lifespan, this weapon light is shock-resistant and offers a concentrated beam for optimal peripheral illumination. The rail grip clamp system ensures swift and secure attachment/detachment without tools and is compatible with Glock-style and MIL-STD-1913 rails.
Pros:
- For robust illumination, one thousand lumens, 20,000-candela peak beam intensity, and a 283-meter beam.
- White LED technology with a 50,000-hour lifetime for durability.
- TIR optic for a concentrated beam and optimum peripheral illumination.
- Versatile rail compatibility, fitting Glock-style, and MIL-STD-1913 rails.
- Quickly secure rail grip clamp system for easy attachment/detachment without tools.
- Keys included for Glock-style, Picatinny, Beretta, S&W, and Sig P320 compatibility.
- User-programmable strobe for tactical advantage.
- Fits existing light-bearing holsters for convenience.
Cons:
- Higher cost compared to the Surefire alternative.
Surefire X300 Ultra vs Streamlight TLR1 HL: Get a Quick Decision
Brightness and Beam Intensity
- Both the X300 Ultra and TLR-1 HL output an impressive 1,000 lumens from two included CR123 batteries
- Lumens indicate the total light output, but beam intensity also matters
- The Streamlight produces around 20,000 candela for a tight, focused beam
- Comparatively, the Surefire only reaches about 11,000 candela, resulting in the broader flood
So, while their lumen ratings match, the Streamlight concentrates that brightness into a more intense central beam, allowing it to reach further downrange compared to the Surefire’s more comprehensive but less intense flood pattern. The Streamlight has the advantage if you need to identify targets at longer distances or punch through fog, smoke or ambient light. However, the Surefire disperses more usable light over a wider area for situational awareness at closer distances.
Batteries and Body Build
- Both lights use two CR123 batteries with a 1.5-hour runtime.
- The aluminium bodies provide durability, with a slight size difference favouring Streamlight’s compact design.
Controls and Mounting System
- Streamlight’s controls cater to right-hand users, with a sensitive paddle for momentary and constant-on functions. Left-hand usage could be more ergonomic.
- Surefire’s controls, while needing adjustment, offer a more robust and precise feel.
- Streamlight’s versatile mounting system accommodates various firearms thanks to multiple interchangeable pieces.
- Surefire’s quick-detach option is contrasted with Streamlight’s quick-detach screw, providing flexibility and ease of use.
Dimensions, Price, and Manufacturing
- Streamlight TLR-1 HL – Approximately $130 at many retailers
- Surefire X300 Ultra – Around $250-290 at most vendors
- Streamlight is notably smaller and more affordable, with parts manufactured overseas.
- Surefire, pricier due to its predominantly US-based production, maintains a larger build.
- Streamlight’s affordability comes from overseas manufacturing, posing a potential drawback for those prioritizing American-made products.
Pros and Cons Of Surefire X300 Ultra vs Streamlight TLR1 HL
Pros and Cons Of Surefire X300 Ultra
- Pros: US manufacturing, robust controls, and overall durability.
- Cons: Weaker candela, pricier.
Pros and Cons Of Streamlight TLR1 HL
- Pros: Affordability, versatile mounting, and a powerful beam.
- Cons: Overseas manufacturing, slightly sensitive controls.
You can quickly decide from this tabular form of Surefire X300 Ultra vs Streamlight TLR1 HL.
| Feature | Surefire X300 Ultra | Streamlight TLR-1 HL |
| Price | Around $250+ (More expensive) | Around $130 (More affordable) |
| Lumens | 1,000 | 1,000 |
| Beam Intensity/Candela | 11,000 (Wider beam) | 20,000 (Tight, long-range beam) |
| Beam Pattern | Flood | Throw |
| Switch Design | Less accessible | Ambidextrous |
| More deliberate | Easier to activate inadvertently | |
| Manufacturing | USA-made | Imported parts, USA assembled |
| Warranty | Ten years | Lifetime |
| Weapon Compatibility | Good. Fewer rail options | Excellent. More rail options, including. |
Now you know the detailed comparison of Surefire X300 Ultra vs Streamlight TLR1 HL. You may also like to read our comprehensive buyer’s guide for Glock laser light.
You may also like to read our comprehensive buyers guide on Streamlight laser light.
Bottom line:
Choosing Surefire X300 Ultra vs Streamlight TLR1 HL becomes a personal journey. The article offers a comprehensive guide to navigating the decision-making process based on performance, budget, and individual preferences. In this vast landscape of firearm accessories, where each light shines uniquely, users are encouraged to embrace informed decision-making. The final selection rests in the hands of those seeking the perfect balance between functionality, cost-effectiveness, and the subtleties of personal preference.